Best overall: Pentel GraphGear 500Best value: Tombow MONO GraphBest for precision: rOtring 600 Black Barrel Mechanical PencilBest for drawing: Koh-i-Noor Mechanical Hardtmuth Lead HolderBest ergonomic design: Pilot Dr. Grip G-Spec Shaker Mechanical Pencil

How we selected the best mechanical pencils

Newcomers to the pencil world might get their senses saturated with the sheer amount of mechanical pencils available in the market right now. After all, a pencil is a pencil. Except that it’s not. That’s why we scoured the internet, including office-supply stores and specialized sites, to see what’s out there, read dozens of user reviews, and tried product after product to find the best one in each category.  We considered design and comfort, paying special attention to how these tools feel in your hand, and if their weight and girth make it easy to write and draw. We also took into account precision, durability, extras such as erasers and rubber grips, and price points.  To make decisions easier, we broke down the winners into different categories—best overall, best value, precision, for art and drawing, and comfort.

Best Mechanical Pencils Reviews & Recommendations

Best overall: Pentel GraphGear 500

Why it made the cut: Yes, Pentel already launched the GraphGear 1000, an allegedly better and improved version of this classic mechanical pencil. But the original GraphGear 500 is really all you need—it’s more affordable, reliable, and unlike its successor, still looks like a classic mechanical pencil. There’s a reason why Japanese retailer Muji made their gravity mechanical pencil line look (and feel) exactly like it. Specs

Metallic mesh gripWeighted at the tipLong 4mm sleeve designColor-coded for 0.3mm, 0.5mm, 0.7mm, and 0.9mm sizes

The metallic mesh grip in the GraphGear 500 allows for great control and embeds the pencil with added weight towards the tip, providing a low center of gravity. This feature is super pleasant to the touch and stays cleaner for longer, unlike those gunk-gathering rubber grips. The metal tip also allows for great precision and incredible durability—I’ve been writing and drawing with my GraphGear 500 for more than five years and it still feels like it did on the first day.  The GraphGear 500 releases the lead through a 4mm lead sleeve, which provides greater visibility of the paper, making it perfect to work on small details or using rulers. This mechanical pencil comes in four different sizes (0.3mm, 0.5mm, 0.7mm, and 0.9mm), and the writing on the barrels is color-coded to reflect that, making it easier to find the exact tool you need for the job. To help with this, the GraphGear 500 also has Pentel’s signature lead grade indicator built into the eraser cap, so you can know exactly what you’ve loaded your pencil with at all times.  No matter how many iterations of this pencil are out there, the original GraphGear 500 is a true classic. If you don’t lose it first, it’ll be putting your ideas on paper for a long time to come.

Best value: Tombow MONO Graph

Why it made the cut: The Tombow MONO graph mechanical pencil is a durable writing tool full of features you won’t have to splurge on.  Specs

Shaker mechanismPlastic body, metallic tipLong twist eraser Comes in 0.5mm and 0.7mm sizes

Tombow is well-known among artists and stationery enthusiasts for their brush pens and markers, and  the Japanese company has also developed its own line of mechanical pencils and erasers under the brand MONO. Their signature MONO graph is a comprehensive writing and drawing tool that will give you a lot of bang for your buck.  It’s designed with a shaker mechanism that pushes the lead out when you move the pencil rapidly up and down. This feature is very convenient, as it doesn’t require you to change your grip on the pencil. If you’re just too used to using your thumb to push the lead, then you can use the clip as a push button. To avoid any mishaps, you can also push the clip up to block the mechanism altogether. This is perfect for storage, as you won’t have to worry about any lead breakage.  Another great feature of the MONO graph is its eraser, which you can twist in and out easily. The eraser is over an inch long and you can buy eraser refills, so you’ll always be able to fix your mistakes.  The body of the Tombow MONO graph is almost entirely made out of plastic, which is something some people just don’t like. Still, the material is durable and the body is on the thicker side, so the pencil has a certain heft that provides control and comfort. The tip is made from a light metallic alloy, and the lead sleeve is not retractable, which may be a bother if you carry the MONO graph in your pocket.

Best for precision: rOtring 600 Black-Barrel Mechanical Pencil

Why it made the cut: rOtring established a new benchmark of precision in 1989 with the launch of the 600-series pencils. These writing tools were designed specifically for technical drawing and durability, a standard that continues today. Specs

Hexagonal shapeAll metallic bodyBuilt-in lead hardness indicatorAvailable in sizes 0.5mm and 0.7mm

The rOtring mechanical pencil can easily last you a lifetime. It’s designed with a full metal body that gives it its 0.8-ounce weight heft. This provides a clear center of gravity, which results in cleaner, more precise lines. Still, this mechanical pencil is more than twice as heavy as the Pentel GraphGear 500, so if you’re not used to this kind of weight, it may take you a bit longer to get used to it.  In addition, the hexagonal shape of the rOtring 600 prevents it from rolling if you’re using an inclined surface, and makes it easier on your hands to draw or write for hours. The gnarled metallic grip is comfortable and makes it easy to hold the pencil without slipping. A lead guidance sleeve helps prevent breakage and gives you an unobstructed view of the page, which is perfect for working out details. Finally, the rOtring 600 has a brass internal mechanism that provides high precision in lead advancement. This means the pencil will push the same length of lead with every press of the button and will keep the lead in place regardless of the pressure you apply. 

Best for drawing: Koh-i-Noor Mechanical Hardtmuth Lead Holder

Why it made the cut: OK, technically, a lead holder is not a mechanical pen, but it shares enough characteristics that it can pass as one. The Koh-i-Noor Mechanical Hardtmuth Lead Holder is a must-have if you don’t want to get your hands dirty while you sketch. Specs

Metal bodyHolds 5.6mm x 80mm leadsBuilt-in metal clipBuilt-in sharpener

At only 4-and-a-half inches long, the Koh-i-Noor Mechanical Lead Holder may be a little short, but it’s thick enough to provide great grip and control. Its inner metallic mechanism holds 5.6mm leads in place no matter how far out you’re using it—you won’t be able to push it or twist it without engaging the push button. This feature can easily make up for the short length of the barrel if you need to handle your pencil from a greater distance.  The full metal body of the Hardtmuth gives it an impressive 1.48-ounce weight—this can be a problem if you’re not used to such a chunky tool, but it’ll be right up your alley if you need a lower center of gravity for your sketching and shading. And the metal clip on the Koh-i-Noor Mechanical Hardtmuth Lead Holder is also sturdy, so you can take it anywhere you want without fear of losing it.

Best ergonomic design: Pilot Dr. Grip G-Spec Shaker Mechanical Pencil

Why it made the cut: Pilot’s Dr. Grip line was created to reduce fatigue and enhance comfort while writing. The ergonomic design behind the Dr. Grip G-Spec mechanical pencil makes writing for hours a breeze. Specs

7.3 x 1.1 x 1.8 inchesPlastic bodyShake mechanismAvailable in sizes 0.5mm and 0.7mm

If you take a lot of notes every day, then you can’t go wrong with Pilot Dr. Grip G-Spec Shaker mechanical pencil. Its ergonomic design consists of a thick body and a rubber grip with a soft inner layer and harder outer layer that provides stability and comfort even after hours and hours of writing.  Just like the Tombow, the Dr. Grip features a shaker mechanism that pushes the lead down the barrel when you shake the pencil up and down. You can also advance the lead the traditional way by pressing the push button on the top, so you always have the option depending on what you find most comfortable at the time.  The Dr. Grip comes in a variety of cool colors, including frost red and frost blue. It comes with an eraser at the top that’s refillable. The body is entirely made out of plastic, so it may not be the most durable mechanical pen, but the forgiving design of this pencil makes it very much worth it if you suffer from pain in your wrists and joints.

Things to consider before buying the best mechanical pencil

Size of lead

The first and most important thing to consider before buying a mechanical pencil is the size. This will determine the type of lead you’ll be able to load into the pencil—the lower the number, the finer the lead. Most pencils come in at least two sizes: 0.5 is the most common, followed by 0.7. The size you get will depend on what you’ll be using your pencil for.  Keep in mind when considering leads that you’ll have the widest range of options when you choose a 0.5-size mechanical pencil. If you want to experiment with colored leads, for example, it’s unlikely that you’ll have a lot to choose from in a 0.3 size.

Material

Next, you’ll need to consider the material the pencil is made of. Full metal bodied pencils are a lot more durable than ones made totally or partially out of plastic, but they tend to be more high-end, making them heavier and pricier. But that doesn’t mean you’ll be compromising quality when going for a full plastic body. Some of these polymers are thick and durable, while others are cheap and easily breakable. Most of the time, the price point is a great sign of what you’re dealing with, but reading reviews will also help you avoid splurging on a low-quality tool.

Location

Finally, think about where your pencil will live. If you plan to keep it on your desk, then you’ll prefer an hexagonal-shaped body to prevent your pencil from rolling off and falling to the floor—possibly to its death or that of the lead within it. If you’ll be carrying around your mechanical pencil in your pocket or in a pencil case, you’re better off with a tool with a retractable lead sleeve. This will avoid lead breakage, but also constantly getting stabbed in the thigh or your ribs, or poking holes in your pencil case.

Final thoughts

It may not seem like it, but the writing or drawing tools you choose to use are our very personal decisions. They don’t necessarily have to be pricey, highly specialized mechanical pens. Depending on what kind of work you do, if you’re on the move a lot, and whether you prefer heavier or lighter tools, your perfect mechanical pencil may not even be among our picks. Still, if you’re new to the wide and varied world of writing instruments, you definitely will not go wrong by choosing any of the items on this list.  And whenever you find something you truly like, stick with it. We recommend purchasing a couple of extra pencils to have in storage, just in case yours gets misplaced, discontinued, or you use it so much, it falls apart in your hands. Definitely not a bad way to go.